Thursday, November 12, 2009

The more you earn, the less money you take home

One basic point is that when multiple income-based programs are piled on top on one another, the implicit marginal tax rate can reach or even exceed 100 percent.

The chart above (source, via Kling) illustrates this phenomenon. It shows income after taxes and transfers as a function of earned income. Notice that as earned income rises from about $15,000 to $30,000, income after taxes and transfers is roughly flat. Indeed, it could even fall. The bottom line: If you are poor, the government is inadvertently ensuring that you have little incentive to try to improve your condition.
--Greg Mankiw on a problem that will get worse with health insurance subsidies that phase out with income

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Maybe it's inadvertent.

Maybe it isn't.

Anyway, throw in the Medicaid "spend all your savings or we take away your health care" rule and it really does seem like a system designed to keep the poor poor.